Archive for June, 2008

Doctor (Rutherford)-Johnson

A portrait of the author, today (subject to minor corrections).

Comments (9)

Musicology and Copyright

Daniel Wolf points to some recent posts to the Society for Music Theory’s email list concerning recent copyright legislation and musicology’s (non-)contribution to the development of such laws. David Huron* initiated the debate with a call for musicologists to become more clued up to issues of copyright, and to do more professionally to guide public policy in such areas. So far the responses have largely been along the lines of “Well, I am/know people who are involved in a musicological study of copyright law”, and that is great. But my personal experience of musicologists (and some musicians even, who have an even greater stake in all this) is that basic knowledge of how the various copyrights in music function is not widespread. Musicological responses to the Lionel Sawkins case a couple of years back ranged from the clued up to the clueless (including one or two who felt comfortable issuing opinions without having read the judgment itself, or any of the other court documents). I’ve said before that if one is a professional creator of intellectual property (which you are as soon as you put pen to paper or bow to string) a basic knowledge of where you and your work stand legally should be a basic tool of your trade.

But the issues for musicology and copyright extend far beyond retaining control of one’s intellectual property, or of knowing how to get permission to use a particular extract in a publication, and it is such matters to which Huron alludes. I need to put together a reading list on the subject to know more precisely where things currently stand scholarship-wise, but some of the issues that should be of grave concern to musicology are:

  • 1. more and more of our cultural output is increasingly held by corporations, who lobby for stricter copyright legislation to protect their investment but restrict free and easy access and dissemination
  • 2. the relevant laws that concern digital archiving, format shifting and backup copies are fragmented, often not up to speed with technology, and frequently restrict the activities of libraries in preserving recorded documents (this is an especially pressing problem with tape recordings, which deteriorate but in many instances cannot legally be copied to a new format for the sake of preservation)
  • 3. with the rise of portable digital technologies it should be easier than ever to preserve a rich archive of cultural activity. This applies especially to music, where audio and video recording of a unique event is now simple. The development of copyright legislation in recent decades, however, has worked to restrict the potential of such technology for preservation, dissemination and study.
  • 4. legal actions – often worth very large sums of money – are now commonplace between copyright holders and other musicians over the appropriation, reuse or simple allusion to prior copyrighted work. Such a legal environment not only restricts creativity but challenges our present concepts of authorship, innovation, musical production, and the nature of the work itself.

All these matters – and there are doubtless more – are of immediate concern to our discipline, and Huron is right to say that musicologists have to become more involved in guiding public policy here. Some are, certainly, but while legislation continues to be passed that strengthens the power of the corporate copyright holder over the creativity of the artist, or restricts society’s potential for cultural preservation (and therefore future development and innovation), then clearly more of us need to be doing more.

*Incidentally, Huron’s Sweet Anticipation: Music and the Psychology of Expectation is discussed in a recent post by Scott Spiegelberg.

Leave a Comment

Exaudi, Spitalfields Festival – Punch up at a première

My review is up at Musical Pointers.

Bonus commentary on the audience interruption – quite the oddest outburst I’ve seen at a concert. Basically, Evan’s piece starts very quietly. Unfortunately, Shoreditch Church has some very creaky pews, and is susceptible to outside noise from police sirens etc, so the piece was already a little interrupted. But still, two guys started whispering to one another, pretty audibly, and the chap sat next to them knocked one of them on the arm and told him to “shush”. At which point Whisperer A starts to exclaim (at shrill volume now), “Don’t hit me! He hit me! Did you see that? Don’t you hit me!” (ad nauseam histrionicam). Whisperer B stands up, laughing, “I’m sorry, I’ve had enough of this, I’m going”. Whisperer A agrees – “He hit me!” (like you’re the one suffering here, mate). A and B exit in the manner of two-year-olds, stamping feet and slamming doors as they go.

Evan Johnson: packing more punch-ups than Stravinsky.

Comments (2)

Tony Conrad at Tate Modern

Tony Conrad weekend at the Tate has just passed. I went to the Saturday and Sunday events – showings of some of his 1980s video work, a late night performance in the Turbine Hall, and a round table discussion with Branden Joseph, author of this recent book. I didn’t see any of the early films though cos they were on at the same time as EXAUDI at Spitalfields (more on which to follow).

Conrad’s video work was all new to me, and I wasn’t entirely sure what to make of some of it. Films like No Europe (positing the idea that white Americans appeared as native aborigines, rather than European immigrants – and thus had a whole bunch of white, middle class sensibilities but no skills, tools or culture appropriate for working the land) were funny but seemed totally out of place among the more experimental stuff to do with the audience/medium/artist relationship (which I found more interesting – eg Concord Ultimatum, Redressing Down and In Line).

The musical performance was much more interesting to me. Very troubling, but very powerful too. The easiest way to describe it is to show you – here are a few photos someone has posted to flickr. And I took a few very amateur sound recordings on my mp3 player:

1. http://www.sendspace.com/file/fpmvo7 – transition between ‘vinyl shish kebab’ and droning strings
2. http://www.sendspace.com/file/c6p47o – droning strings
3. http://www.sendspace.com/file/5wfu6u – more droning strings – towards the end; also walking around so you get some sense of the ‘power noise’ vs ‘drone’ aspects of the sound design.

The performers were on the bridge/balcony that is in the middle of the Turbine Hall, and the performance area was shrouded on its two open sides with these massive white sheets. They were raised just enough that you could see the performers underneath, but they were also backlit and their shadows projected 40-foot high onto these screens. You could walk under the bridge and see these projections from either end of the Hall. Each end of the hall was surrounded by an immense soundsystem that amplified the performers – and emphasised different channels of the sound output (so more noise at one end than the other).

Basically the performance was in three chunks, two shortish, one much longer. In the first (which I didn’t record, but some of the photos show) TC was using a HUGE power drill to bore holes into blocks of wood and reels of film stock – recreating Boring Film. This film was projected onto the screens later in the set.

In the second he got out his vinyl kebab – basically a stack of LPs attached to a long drill bit, attached to the drill itself. So the records are spinning at 100s of rpm or whatever, and TC is playing them with two handheld tone arms. You get some of this at the start of the first extract.

The third section was much more conventional – essentially lots of string drones that ebbed and flowed and generated lots of lovely difference tones. There was also a ton of noise overlaid with effects pedals, drills, electric hums etc (some of which were generated by the Tate’s one remaining turbine itself).

The whole lot was deafeningly loud. Moving around the hall was physically oppressive, especially as you walked in and out of range of the various speakers. The first section, with TC’s shadow (with his hat) looming like a maniac with a drill, was terrifying.Rainforests, glaciers and Xenakis are awesome; Conrad is frightening, like climate change. On my way home I was physically discomfited – not just ringing ears, but ringing skin. I had to wash the sound off me before I could sleep.

This all threw up a bunch of issues that bothered me. By design, any installation in the Turbine Hall is a massive ego trip; this one in particular in which the figure of the artist (literally) looms so large over his subjected audience. The commitment of resources – not just electricity etc but also the physical investment of people’s ear drums – I found very troubling. The actual aesthetic point didn’t seem enough; the best justification from an audience point of view was a sort of blissed out, transcendentalism (accompanied by a total submission to TC’s will) – which is kind of unsatisfactory. But then again, it was an extraordinary experience that I’m glad to have had, and I don’t doubt TC’s artistic sincerity – there was nothing cheap or tawdry here.

In the round table on Sunday afternoon, some of these questions were put to TC, who was unusually unconvincing in his response – he argued that this all had to be seen in the context of his complete output, which has always tackled issues of power etc. He also mentioned sado-masochism, but I didn’t really get that since the issues of consent and so on in an S&M context and in an art gallery seem quite different to me. I’d be interested to hear thoughts from anyone else who was there.

Comments (2)

Music You’d Like to Hear

Music We’d Like to Hear, the subtle smorgasbord of experimental music curated by John Lely, Tim Parkinson and Marcus Trunk, is back next month. I commend these concerts to you all.

http://www.musicwedliketohear.com/

tim parkinson
2nd july 2008
still/s 1-6

richard emsley: still/s part 1 to 6 of the 24-part cycle (2002-2008 )
4, 5 & 6: mwlth commissions, with support from the Britten-Pears Foundation

markus trunk
9th july 2008
organ and silence

tom johnson: organ and silence
erik satie: sonneries de la rose + croix
jürg frey: sam lazaro bros
laurence crane: the swim
paul newland: una corda
christian wolff: tilbury 3

john lely
16th july 2008
portrait of michael parsons (b. 1938 )

michael parsons: highland variations (1972); krapp music (1999); levels (2007)
cornelius cardew: string trio II
anton webern: string quartet op.28
purcell/parsons: 4 part fantasia no.9

performers:
apartment house
james weeks, organ
tim parkinson, piano
the post quartet with michael parsons

7:30 church of st anne & st agnes, gresham street, london ec2 7bx
£9 (£6)

Leave a Comment

JSTOR to go free?

Comments (6)

Online classical radio listings

I’ve been sent a link to what claims to be the world’s largest collection of online classical music radio stations. I don’t know if that’s true, but it looks like a pretty extensive list to me. Do give it a browse.

Leave a Comment

Musician Deathwatch

del.icio.us/skills/obituary | About this list

This week we bid farewell to the following members of the musical community:

:: U. Utah Phillips Folk singer and political activist
:: David Gahr Photographer who specialised in musicians
:: Earle Hagen TV composer
:: John Cruft Orchestral oboist and Arts Council secretary
:: Jimmy McGriff Jazz and blues organist
:: Mickey Waller Jeff Beck drummer
:: Kishan Maharaj Tabla player
:: Sonny Okosuns Singer
:: Siegmund Nissel Violinist with the Amadeus Quartet
:: Bob Florence Jazz pianist, bandleader and arranger
:: Franz Jackson Jazz saxophonist
:: Milo M. Velimirovic Musicologist
:: Dick Charlesworth Trad-jazz clarinettist
:: Wilfrid Mellers Musicologist and composer
:: Hugh McElrath Musicologist
:: Larry Levine Record engineer for Phil Spector
:: Muriel More Country dance pianist
:: Edmund Barham Operatic tenor
:: Joyce ‘Dottie’ Rambo Gospel singer and songwriter
:: Mary Berry Musicologist of Gregorian chant
:: Wilfred Middlebrooks Jazz bassist
:: Ruben Vartanyan Conductor
:: Leyla Gencer Operatic soprano
:: Jerry Wallace Country singer
:: John P. Hennessey Rhythm bones player
:: Tony Kostrzewa Founder of Red Rhino Records
:: Eddy Arnold Country singer
:: Frances Yeend Operatic soprano
:: Ilyas Malayev Uzbek musician and poet
:: LonPaul Ellrich Indie drummer, instrumentalist and producer

Rest in Peace.

Comments (6)